Can AI truly reason, or is it just a fancy
Late Addition: ChatGPT-o1 was revealed during this process and you can skip to that section for the latest.
The Birthday Puzzle Challenge
I set out to replicate and expand on experiments conducted by the
“Cheryl’s Birthday” is a logic problem where Bernard and Albert must deduce Cheryl’s birthday from a set of clues. It tests deductive reasoning and information processing.
Here’s what I found:
-
The Original Puzzle: Most AIs solved it with ease. (Except you, Gemini. What happened there?)
-
Name-Swapped Version: Nearly all AIs stumbled when we renamed the actors and swapped months and numbers to random words.
The Cake Conundrum
Now, here’s where it gets interesting (and a little concerning). The variation replaced Bernard with Edgar and May 19th with “brinks cake.” I added one tiny, irrelevant detail:
“Edgar has a sweet tooth”
The results? Suddenly, our AI friends developed a serious cake obsession:
Reasonable(?) Carrot Cake
ChatGPT-o1’s advanced methods are a breakthrough. Its chain of reasoning sees past the obfuscation far more than any competitor.
The breakthrough still stumbles on its sweet tooth though. Interestingly, it can rule out “cake” but then picks “Carrot” because that was the sweetest remaining (and yet wrong) option:
Why This Matters (A Lot)
-
Reasoning vs. Regurgitating: These experiments cast doubt on whether AI is truly “reasoning” or just really good at pattern matching.
-
Easy to Manipulate: A single, irrelevant sentence dramatically shifts AI responses. Imagine the implications for more complex queries!
-
RAG and Sensitive Data: If AI struggles with simple logic puzzles, how can we trust it to parse through our confidential documents and extract meaningful insights?
-
Manufacturing “Truth”: Systems that generate multiple AI responses and aggregate them for increased accuracy could be easily swayed by carefully placed suggestions.
The Cake is a Lie (Portal Reference Intended)
This isn’t just about birthday puzzles and dessert preferences. It’s a wake-up call for any organization considering AI for critical decision-making processes.
We need:
Until then, approach AI-generated insights with a healthy dose of skepticism. AI’s promise is tantalizing, but we can’t let it eat our cake and have it, too.
