Fact check: Did an AI country song reach No. 1 on Billboard?

You can’t believe everything you hear.

This week, I saw dozens of headlines and viral social posts about an AI country song that reached the top of the Billboard country charts. If a song created with generative AI had truly reached No. 1 in the country music world, that would indeed be huge, paradigm-shifting news.

I’m talking about “Walk My Walk” by Breaking Rust, the name of an AI-generated “musician.” Meanwhile, as social media users breathlessly shared news about the AI country song topping the chart, a human being by the name of Morgan Wallen has been the actual artist at the top of the Billboard country chart. (I reached out to Billboard for comment, and I’ll update this post if I receive a response.)

So, what’s going on? Technically, “Walk My Walk” has nabbed the top spot on a chart. Specifically, the Billboard Country Digital Song Sales Chart. However, as any music listener can tell you, there aren’t many people buying digital copies of singles anymore. Over on Spotify’s Country Top 50 chart, Breaking Rust is nowhere to be found — even after all the news coverage this past week.

As is often the case, social media doesn’t quite have the story right on this one. On YouTube, the song has a measly 38,944 views, as of this writing.

As someone who grew up in the South and listened to a lot of country pop against his will, I can tell you that a lot of such ditties sound exactly the same. Pop country loves its tropes and has been parodied to death, and “Walk My Walk” hits a lot of the usual cliches. The lyrics include poetry like “Got mud on my jeans” and, ironically, “I was born this way.” Even the title of the song and name of the “musician” are painfully generic.

Indeed, it’s hard to think of a more hackneyed country song title than “Walk My Walk,” and what does Breaking Rust actually mean? It’s exactly the kind of country-sounding but soulless name you’d expect from generative AI.

On first listen, there’s not much to distinguish this song from any other country or Bluegrass pop hit, at least to my ears. But that’s not praise for generative AI so much as it’s criticism of the genre. And, of course, if “Walk My Walk” sounds like a real country song, that’s because it was surely made by an AI audio model trained on countless real country songs, without the permission or consent of the artists. A lot of artists consider generative AI to be outright theft and plagiarism, at an industrial scale.

According to The Tennessean, Breaking Rust songs are credited to Aubierre Rivaldo Taylor, an unknown creator with no online presence.

Whether you like it or not, AI creators aren’t going away. I’ve written about the bizarre phenomenon of AI “actors” before, and you can expect more AI-generated songs, movies, books, and slop to appear in your feeds from now on, and possibly forever.

This article reflects the opinion of the writer.

Disclosure: Ziff Davis, Mashable’s parent company, in April filed a lawsuit against OpenAI, alleging it infringed Ziff Davis copyrights in training and operating its AI systems.