Examples of bill-credit subsidies offered by T-Mobile
Comparing old subsidized plans with today’s plans
One thing to point out. Customers complained in the old days of being locked to their carrier for two years. But what many fail to understand is that they are still locked in with the modern monthly bill credits. Let’s explore this. In the old days, you’d pay $199 for a $649 iPhone. You would sign a two-year contract. Leaving early would invoke the Early Termination Fee (ETF) which would cost you $150 to $300. These days, you finance a new phone over 24–36 months and the carrier gives you a monthly bill credit that reduces the monthly cost of the device. If you leave before the finance period ends, you owe immediately for the unpaid balance of the phone, which could amount to $800-$1,000.
While T-Mobile didn’t officially commit itself to the end of subsidies earlier this week, the conversation during the earnings call was more about how current subsidies might evolve. T-Mobile CEO Gopalan said that today’s higher priced and longer-lasting phones change the economics of subsidies. The executive stated that the new talk about subsidies is focused on sustained value and customer lifetime value. Right now we might not know exactly what that means, but eventually we will.
Competition between Verizon, AT&T, and T-Mobile is fierce
I could tell you that this exciting new future for subsidized phones was behind the big move in the carrier’s stock on Thursday, which took it as high as $220.84 before closing at $214.68, up $5.14 or 2.45% on the day. But the actual reason for the stock hike was a higher multi-year outlook estimated by the company during the same earnings call where Srini Gopalan brought up subsidies. In addition, Goldman Sachs and Barclays raised their price targets on the stock, leading institutional investors to add to their holdings.
It’s interesting that many of our younger readers might not remember the old subsidized contracts that allowed me to buy a phone like the Motorola DROID for only $199 as long as I remained a Verizon customer for two years. It’s kind of odd that the carriers didn’t want to give up those subsidies at first because, with the modern-day subsidies, they make out much better with the modern subsidy plan.
